Make some memories in Cortland and go fishing with RJ & Sons Charters. Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Richard can tell you all about them. Depending on the time of year, you might hook into Catfish, and whatever else is biting.
Based out of Geneva, Cam Sportfishing is your ticket to a memorable time on the water. Capt.
"Our group of six had an amazing day! Filled the cooler and was off the water in 6 1/2 hours!" — Bennett,
If you're ready to start fishing in Geneva-on-the-Lake, we've got you covered with Byler's Sportfishing Charters. Walleye, and more inhabit these waters if you cast your line at the right time of year. For these species, you're likely to troll.
"Melbern knows what he´s doing. He got us to a promising fishing spot, set up the trolling rods, and the fish were biting!" — Evelyn,
Turner Loose Charters and Guide Robert E. Turner welcome you to Ashtabula, Ohio.
"Captain Bob was excellent! Weather report had been iffy for days." — Donald,
If you plan on fishing in Geneva-on-the-Lake, look no further than Big eye charters. Captain Mike knippenberg will be your guide, which allows you to benefit from their professional experience.
Mosquito Creek Outfitters is owned and operated by captain Chad Fenstermaker. He's been catching Walleye since he was old enough to hold a rod and it's always been his biggest passion.
"We had a great time and caught lots or walleye. Chad is efficient, friendly, and ensured we got on plenty of fish!" — Jules,
There's a fish with your name on it in Ashtabula and Team Herman Sport Fishing will help you catch it! The fish in these waters include Walleye and the occasional tackle thrashing Steelhead.
"We had a great day on the lake. Nice boat. Good equipment. And a first class crew." — Daniel,
Spend the day with Keepin It Reel and let them show you what makes the fishing in Geneva-on-the-Lake so memorable! Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Nick is prepared to put you on fish.
"Great Captain Nick- max catch and several over 20”++, nice to have a bathroom and lots of room for fishing ." — John,
Lake Erie is known as one of the finest lakes to fish on in the world.
"Great conversations. Very relaxed. Super engaged and helpful and they stayed on the fish!" — Scott,
Cortland sits beside Mosquito Creek Lake, one of Northeast Ohio's most accessible freshwater playgrounds. Sheltered coves, broad flats, and miles of shoreline create a versatile fishery that welcomes first-timers and seasoned anglers alike. With Cortland fishing charters, you can explore structure-rich areas where game fish hunt and feed throughout the seasons.
Expect a classic Midwest mix of targets. Walleye prowl drop-offs and windswept points, crappie school around brush and submerged timber, and bass—both largemouth and smallmouth—ambush along weedlines and rocky edges. Bluegill keep rods bending for families, while channel catfish offer hard-pulling action after dark or in stained water. Local captains tailor trips to the bite, from precise jig and live-bait presentations to trolling passes that cover water efficiently.
Timing matters here. Spring brings crappie into the shallows and fires up bass on warming banks. Summer mornings and evenings shine for bass and walleye, with steady panfish action near vegetation. Fall cools the lake and often concentrates walleye on structure, rewarding patient anglers. When conditions allow in winter, ice anglers capitalize on panfish and the occasional walleye over mid-lake humps.
Easy launches, protected water, and nearby amenities make Cortland a convenient base for a day—or a long weekend—on the lake. Book Cortland fishing charters to tap into local knowledge and turn Mosquito Creek Lake's seasonal patterns into steady hookups.
